Better Than Sex BBQ Sauce- Extra Tingly

Mo Heat Level: 5
  • $9.95
  • Buy TWO BOTTLES- Save!
  • $19.10
  • Buy SIX BOTTLES- Save!
  • $56.95

Better Than Sex BBQ sauce now comes in Extra Tingly for those of you who like a sizzle in the grill!! From the BBQ geniuses Janet and Wiley McCrary comes the extra tingly version of the wildly famous Original Better Than Sex BBQ. This sauce is perfect on ribs, chicken, beef, pork or other body parts that need a little tingle!!


Shipping Weight: 18 oz


Write a review

Absolutely the Best
Jul 8, 2011  |  By Mike M
Absolutely the best all around BBQ I have ever tasted. Great on pork, chicken and beef. Little sweet and heat. Great for competition and for the backyard. If you visit Savannah its the same sauce they have on the tables!

Aug 6, 2011  |  By Floyd Neimeyer
great sauce

Mucho Goodo
Aug 30, 2011  |  By Paul W. Harris
That's what my blonde wife said with her bad spanish. She just says every thing with an "O" at the end. But it really is fantastic sauce.Everyone that has tried it, just loves it.

Mucho Goodo
Aug 30, 2011  |  By Paul W. Harris
That's what my blonde wife said with her bad spanish. She just says every thing with an "O" at the end. But it really is fantastic sauce.Everyone that has tried it, just loves it.

tingly and tasty
Apr 6, 2012  |  By Sara Krapf
Loved this one as well!

Not very Tingley
Apr 14, 2013  |  By Mike
We liked the original so much we wanted to try the extra tingley, however, this tasted sooooooo much like the original we thought it was mislabeled, just no real extra heat to this one. Stick with the original.

The tinglier the better
Oct 5, 2013  |  By Sara Krapf
I'm not a "spicy, hot" lover of BBQ sauce but this one is terrific!

Great sauce
Mar 23, 2014  |  By Geri
We ate here twice when we were in Savannah. Loved their food & loved the BBQ sauce. Did want to buy the sauce when we were there, but did not want to carry it. All 8 of us ordered sauce together & there was no shipping & no tax. Great deal!!

Better Than Sex
May 13, 2014  |  By David Blasky
This is the best all around BBQ sauce i have ever had, we're addicted to it.

Sep 20, 2014  |  By Trix
This sauce is great!!!! My husband uses it for everything!! lol...

Oct 3, 2014  |  By Fred T
Has a little bit of Heat with a great taste. My family really enjoys this BBQ Sauce. I would like more heat to it. That of course is just my opinion. I am sure that if you try it you will like it.

Best Ever
Dec 18, 2014  |  By amy
We have loved this sauce since we ate at their restaurant in Savannah- hands down the best sauce we've ever had. Great flavor and texture, and just the right amount of spice!

Best BBQ Sauce I've Consumed
Jan 23, 2015  |  By Zak G
I first experienced this sauce in the restaurant in Savannah. It is the best BBQ sauce I've eaten - hands down. Extremely flavorful with a decent kiss of spice. I probably could survive the rest of my life with only this sauce (and maybe good, real sweet chili sauce) in my pantry. I always have at least a spare bottle on hand. Since I live in Pittsburgh, I buy it from here, and have been pleased with their services. Try the sauce - you won't regret it.

Feb 20, 2015  |  By Jamie
Hands down the best BBQ sauce I have ever tasted. A friend recommended this. And I cannot live without my pulled BBq chicken and pork was amazing thanks to this BBQ sauce. You will not be disappointed.

Awesome Sauce!
Jul 12, 2015  |  By Kevin Lingg
Great service, quick shipping, and some of the best BBQ I have ever had. I will be purchasing again in the future!

Jun 20, 2017  |  By Kathy
This is great BBQ. We visited Wiley's BBQ in Savannah and just to have more.

Mar 7, 2018  |  By sue morelli
my nephew loved it

Best hot sauce
Aug 19, 2018  |  By Richard Swearingen
I've tried many hot sauces but this is the best.

Oct 18, 2020  |  By Earl Smith
I purchased Better Than Sex after trying it at a friends that had stopped to eat in the past.

BBQ Sauce
Dec 28, 2020  |  By Robert B. Petersen
The "Better than Sex" BBQ sauces live up to their name. Ordered original and extra tingly many times.

great sauce
Mar 1, 2021  |  By Sara Krapf
We have enjoyed your sauce for years & continue to

Mar 10, 2021  |  By Bernard Shuemate
One of the best BBQ sauces I've tried.

Addictive bbq sauce
Jul 19, 2021  |  By Susan Brown
We went to Wiley's during a recent trip to Savannah. Loved the BBQ sauce, bought a bottle and wanted more. So glad we can get it online. It is the best we've ever had.

Jun 4, 2022  |  By Brian
I am from PA, and we decided to try the restaurant that has the Better than Sex BBQ Sauces. We were astonished with the flavors, that we had 16 bottles shipped home from Savannah, GA. I will be ordering these products often.

Pricy but the best.
Aug 25, 2022  |  By Philip J Marquez
The best BBQ sauce I've found and I've been through many BBQ joints in Texas and KC. I actually discovered it while eating at Wiley's in Savannah. Get's a 4 star due to price but no matter I will still order it to ensure I never run out. If I didn't consider price, it's ABSOLUTELY 5 star! If you can't take the heat, get the Original instead of Extra Tingly

Nov 29, 2022  |  By Ken
I tried out this sauce a few months ago and I liked it more than expected, so I re-ordered. The label says "extra tingly" but don't be afraid -- it's not extra hot - just tingly!

Suggested Products